Hello to all, Hello to myself,
Today, I was pondering…. when is a question really a question.
I think people would say that they ask questions all the time. Like… What this…? How did that…? Why that other thing…stuff?
But is every utterance that starts with a Who, What, When, Where, Why, or How… truly a question?
I am going to say “No”. Here is my premise… A question is only truly a question when the asker is ‘open’ or ‘accepting’ to whatever the asked person provides in response. It is not a true question when we have predetermined the acceptable answer(s). It is not a question, if we are expecting or leading the respondent to our desired outcome.
We are not ‘asking’ anything, if the asked person doesn’t have a choice or even the freedom to exist without judgement after they have given their answer.
Under the above terms, it is hard to think of how many true questions I have asked or been asked in my life. Maybe, the idea of a question and judgement are intrinsically connected. But, I don’t believe that is the Truth or even part of the path to the Truth. I am saddened when I think about how defensive, combative, and fearful we are in regular communication with anyone (a friend, a stranger, a loved one). The majority of the questions we ask others are not a pure expression of unknowing or wonder; they are a defensive, leading, dictating, or fear-driven gesture to keep the truth hidden… to mask our true identities.
How can you find the Truth without asking a question. What is the answer?
I don’t know, but I do want to ask the question. And, I want to be open to and accepting of the answer…
Thank you for being, Michael.